Ok a little help, I’m planning on doing one of the post WWII Panthers built and operated by the French army, my questions are what would be the best base 1/35 kit to start with (no interior) and what mods need to be done?
I don’t know anything about the Panthers operated by the French except they did operate them so any help appreciated.
From memory, I think the French were able to repurpose enough Panthers to form a complete Regt after the war ended. and I have seen images of Panther A & G, to keep it nice and easy, I would look at the basic Tamiya Panther G’s with or without Zimm or a Panther A with Zimm from another company.
The Chars Francais website is very useful here; this is what it says - amongst other details:
After the end of World War II, the French Army temporarily equipped certain units with captured tanks. 49 tanks were reconditioned and used by various units or for experiments until the end of 1950.
The 503rd RCC and the 6th RC were partially equipped with Panther Type A and G tanks.
I do not think that all 49 were ever effectively operational and the Osprey book, “Foreign Panthers” expands on this at length, and also offers up that they operated alongside the ARL 44 up to 1952. Spares were the biggest problem which wasn’t helped by the fact that the US forbade any transfer of Panthers (in their zone) to the French. When looked after and properly maintained, we all know that the Panther was a hugely effective tank, but even with extensive cannibalisation, eventually continued maintenance was a problem, and the Osprey book reports that something like only a squadron’s (company’s) worth were ultimately in running order ie around 15 tanks.
Whilst a mix of A and G, I doubt the French would have bothered milling off the Zimmerit on any they had - though they might have. For my model, made in 2018, I selected this Tamiya G:
though they may never had had one quite as pristine as mine. I thought that the MGs might be replaced and utilised a 3D Reibel as replacements. I further reasoned that US comms kit might also be fitted and went for that; lastly, due to the comms fit I thought that conceivably US tank helmets would be worn and depicted the Commander equipped as such. I admit to no evidence whatsoever for any of this - however, I think it plausible and it sort of Frenchifies it all (including the yellow-tinted headlamp). A few shots of my efforts:
which is not to say it’s accurate as I refer to; however, perhaps a modicum of inspiration to those intending to tackle the subject. It does - to me - look very different in its new plumage.
The obvious choice is a late Panther G. There are a lot of really good, modern Panther G models currently in production. Even the el-cheapo Takom Panther G would work. (I vaguely remember seeing some solid guide horn tracks on French Panthers.) I would throw the Dragon Panther Gs from the 2000s in there as well. Those are really good models.
I have build a half dozen Dragon Panthers and a Meng Jagdpanther. I like Dragon Panther Gs a lot. If I were to do what you are doing, I would start with the el cheapo Takom Panther G. If money was no object, I would use a Rye Field Panther G because Rye Field. I would not bother with Academy, ICM, Italeri, or Tamiya unless one dropped into my hands super cheap as a painting experiment. That does not mean they are bad. Based on my reading, I would go with other brands first. No opinion on Hobby Boss or Takom. Das Werk Panthers are all Takom. Eventually hope to build em all.
No idea on modifications. When I looked into this, French Panthers seemed all or mostly stock but I am not a super expert and did not dig out the books and dissect pictures.
Hopefully, someone who did a deep dive on this can help you. I plan on purchasing the linked book before building my French Panther.
Edit: The very first thing I would do is took at the tracks on my subject Panther. Are they open or solid guide horn? That would narrow my choice of model. Then I would look at tool stowage. If the subject has German tool stowage and I want that to be super accurate, I would pick a model with really good stowage parts, down to the retaining pins and chains. If the subject does not use German tool stowage, more models will qualify.
The aim was to, hopefully, inspire Luciano and offer up a few references - the website CharsFrancais, and the Osprey book, though I’m not suggesting that one has to purchase the book by any means.
My plan is to display my Panther as part of my planned “French Collection” - geddit? Anyway, not much done so far, but hopefully next year I’ll get around to completing my ARL-44 (stalled for some inexplicable reason), throw in an M47 - AMX 13 VTT combo, and repair my AMX 30. That should keep me going:
I know, this is just a map I pulled off Wikimedia Commons to do a quick mockup. It would be better for decals to draw around it by hand to get rid of all of the detail (Illustrator’s Simplify function makes hardly any difference, even at full strength.)