Campaign suggestion: Tracks but no tanks!

Group Build Title: Tracks but no tanks!

Group Build Leader(s): @golikell

Group Build Description: Any tracked vehicle but a tank.
Think about ARV’s IFV’s, Amtracks, SPG’s, Bulldozers, etc. Basically it should not have a rotating turret with a main gun designed for direct fire and (relatively) heavy armored. Tank destroyers, like M10 or M36 are an exception to the rule, but the early British rhomboid ones not, as the turret had not been introduced yet. But I think most of you guys know well enough if something qualifies as a tank or not.

Event Details: (Remember to click “Going” if you want to join the build!)

Completion Award:

image_c165632a

4 Likes

I myself will enter Takoms’ Bergepanther ausf A. in this build:

2 Likes

Would an Anti Aircraft " tank" count as a tank? As it does have a rotating turret? But it doesn’t have a heavy main direct fire support gun?

1 Like

Like a Cruiser AA, Wirbelwind or Sgt. York? Sure! Though they use the chassis of a tank, they have a special role, unlike the tank, which is considered multi-role.

2 Likes

Yep or a ZSU 52 etc? Also what about something like a Stug that has the main gun assembly made, casement roof, partial rear deck and lower hull and some wheels made, but not put together?


Cheers
Mike

2 Likes

ZSU is the same category.

As for the STUG, I believe the general rule of thumb is no more than 25% build already. How far are you according to your own estimation?

1 Like

A tank is a fully tracked, fully enclosed, fully armored vehicle with any form of gun, including a machine gun. That meets the original definition of tank as defined by the British people who introduced the term.

1 Like

That definition might have been correct in the beginning, but a tank destroyer is not considered a tank, as it has a dedicated role in only destroying tanks. Tank destroyers, aa tanks and the like were not even thought of yet, so the definition shifted in time.

2 Likes

Good question, I will check the part count of the kit, and then how parts i have put together.

2 Likes

Not counting tracks (200) scalemates says there are 378 parts, for ease of math, I will round up to 400, but dismiss (178) track parts, I don’t believe that I have assembled 100 parts, have I cut about 100 parts of the sprues, would be close, but about half of them still require cleaning up etc. But I am happy to abide by your choice, I do have other options if I decide to join in. :grin:

1 Like

Only cutting them off does not count in my opinion. So, I’d say, join the fun… If you doubt it yourself, a ZSU will just be as fine :smiley:

1 Like

It is your campaign! You have compete control of what qualifies and what does not. :slight_smile:

I was commenting on the fundamental question of what “tank” means. There are a lot of definitions out there and many people clearly struggle with the concept.

The definition should encompass the machine the term was coined for. Clearly, if a given definition does not encompass a British Mark I Tank, that definition cannot be correct. For this reason, requiring a turret is out.

I also feel the inventors of the term have far more precedence for definition value than people who come along later. It does not matter what some Major or Public Relations person thinks. The original meaning based on the ideas of the people who coined the term should have precedence.

“Tank destroyer” is an interesting term because it is a role, not a machine body plan.

To be clear, I really like the campaign idea! It covers a lot of ground and stimulates discussion of a very interesting question. What is a tank?

I will build a Tamiya RSO when the time comes–the tracked truck version, not the tank destroyer version. :slight_smile: Unless I change my mind, of course.

1 Like

Great idea! :slight_smile:

I am thinking a whirlbelwind or an Elefant tank destroyer.

2 Likes

I get where you are coming from and don’t want to end up in an do-do not argument at all, but initial definitions do shift over time. A Little Willy, Whippet, Mark 1 to 5 or A7V are originally incepted as tanks. And the original definition certainly applies to them. But if you keep at this, a M113 ACAV will be counted in too: it is all round (lightly, but so was a Renault FT) armoured, tracked and has a machinegun. Less knowledgeable people would call it a tank, I know (heck, they even call a Fennek wheeled armoured recce vehicle a tank) but it obviously is not.

As for the tankdestroyer, is indeed is a role, but the role clearly has spawned several dedicated designs: M10, M36, Panzerjager 4, Jagdpanther, Hetzer, Jagdtiger, Elefand (Ferdinand), etc. So you can also call it a category of vehicles.

The RSO (Raupenschlepper Ost, not Rad Schlepper Ost (just to differentiate)) will fit perfectly ofcourse!

1 Like

Good choice :smiley:

2 Likes

Many journalists label a BMP-1 as “tank” …
sigh

2 Likes

Yeah, that is what I mean…
This is a Fennek and yet called a “tank” in newspapers…

1 Like


?

1 Like

:man_facepalming: :rofl:

1 Like

Ok, then there are always exceptions when you try to define what you think that can or cannot be included.:roll_eyes:

2 Likes